9 Gold IRA Mistakes That Will Cost You Thousands

I have spent the last three years researching gold IRAs, talking to dealers, and managing my own self-directed precious metals account. Along the way, I have watched smart people lose thousands of dollars to mistakes that were completely avoidable. I made two of these mistakes myself. One cost me sleep. The other nearly cost me money.

The gold IRA industry has a problem: most of the "educational" content out there is just a sales funnel dressed up as advice. Nobody wants to talk about the ways investors actually get burned, because that conversation does not sell gold. I am going to have that conversation anyway.

Here are nine gold IRA mistakes I have seen firsthand, what each one costs in real dollars, and exactly how to avoid them. If you are considering a precious metals IRA, read this before you sign anything.

Mistake 1: Doing an Indirect Rollover Instead of a Direct Rollover

This is the most expensive mistake on the list, and it happens more often than you would think.

There are two ways to move retirement funds into a gold IRA. A direct rollover sends money straight from your old custodian to your new self-directed IRA custodian. You never touch the check. An indirect rollover sends the check to you first, and then you have exactly 60 calendar days to deposit it into the new account.

Miss that 60-day window? The IRS treats every dollar as a taxable distribution. Under 59 and a half? Add a 10% early withdrawal penalty on top. On a $60,000 rollover, that is potentially $18,000 or more in taxes and penalties. Gone. Because of a deadline.

It gets worse with 401(k) plans. Your old employer is required to withhold 20% for federal taxes on an indirect rollover. So you receive a check for $48,000 on your $60,000 rollover, but you still need to deposit the full $60,000 into the new IRA within 60 days. That means finding $12,000 out of pocket to cover the gap. You get the withheld amount back at tax time, but only if you deposited the full amount on schedule.

I did a direct rollover both times I moved retirement money into gold. No withholding, no countdown timer, no anxiety. Every gold IRA company I have worked with pushes direct rollovers for exactly this reason. If someone suggests an indirect rollover and a direct option exists, ask why. There is almost never a good answer.

What it costs: 20% to 35% of your rollover amount in taxes and penalties. On a $50,000 rollover, that is $10,000 to $17,500.

How to avoid it: Request a direct rollover. Period. If your old plan administrator cannot do a trustee-to-trustee transfer (which is rare), get that in writing and talk to a tax professional before proceeding. My gold IRA rollover guide covers the full process step by step.

Mistake 2: Buying Numismatic Coins Instead of Bullion

This one makes me angry, because the investor almost never comes up with this idea on their own. A dealer pushes it.

Numismatic coins are collectibles priced based on rarity, condition, and collector demand. They carry markups of 30% to 80% over their actual metal content. A dealer might sell you a "rare" gold coin for $3,200 when the gold inside it is worth $2,000. You are underwater from the moment you buy it. That coin needs to appreciate 60% just for you to break even, and collector coin prices are wildly unpredictable.

Standard IRA-eligible bullion (American Gold Eagles, Gold Buffalos, Canadian Maple Leafs, PAMP Suisse bars) carries much smaller premiums, typically 3% to 8% over spot price. Your returns track the actual gold price. That is the whole point of buying gold for your retirement account.

Some dealers push numismatics because the profit margins are enormous. They make 5% to 10% selling you a Gold Eagle. They make 30% to 50% selling you a graded collector coin. Follow the incentive and you will understand why a rep might steer you toward "rare" coins.

I bought standard bullion for my IRA: Gold Eagles, Silver Eagles, and a PAMP Suisse bar. Boring? Maybe. But my returns actually reflect where gold prices go, which is the entire reason I own gold in the first place. For the full list of what the IRS allows (and what it bans), see my IRA-eligible metals guide.

What it costs: 20% to 50% of your purchase, gone to inflated premiums before the gold moves a penny. On a $50,000 purchase, that could be $10,000 to $25,000 in unnecessary markups.

How to avoid it: Only buy standard bullion products for your IRA. If a dealer starts talking about "numismatic value" or "collector premiums," that is your cue to find a different dealer.

Mistake 3: Rolling Over Too Much of Your Retirement

Gold is a hedge. It is not a growth engine. I need to be blunt about that, even though I am clearly someone who believes in owning physical metals.

I have heard from investors who converted 80% or even 100% of their retirement savings into gold and silver. Some did it during the 2020 uncertainty. Others were talked into it by overly aggressive dealers who earn commissions on the full amount. In both cases, they gave up the growth potential of equities and bonds for an asset class that, historically, keeps pace with inflation but does not consistently beat it.

Most financial planners suggest 5% to 15% of your total retirement portfolio in precious metals. I went with roughly 15%, and I consider that the upper bound of what is responsible for my situation. Could I be wrong? Sure. Gold might outperform everything for the next decade. But building a retirement plan around that bet is gambling, not investing.

The dealers I trust never pressured me to roll over more than made sense. Augusta, in particular, asked about my full financial picture during our consultation and actually suggested I keep a larger percentage in equities than I had planned. That kind of advice, where the dealer recommends you give them less money, tells you something about their integrity.

What it costs: Decades of compounding stock market growth you will never get back. If you put $200,000 entirely into gold instead of a 15/85 gold-to-stocks split, you could miss out on hundreds of thousands in growth over a 20-year horizon, assuming historical averages hold.

How to avoid it: Set a target allocation before you talk to any dealer. Write it down. Stick to it. If a rep pushes you beyond that number, hang up.

Mistake 4: Ignoring Fee Structures Until It Is Too Late

Gold IRAs are more expensive to maintain than standard brokerage IRAs. Not a little more expensive. Meaningfully more expensive. And the industry does not make it easy to figure out the total cost before you commit.

Here is what you are actually paying for a gold IRA:

• Setup fee: $50 to $150 (often waived for larger accounts)
• Annual custodian fee: $75 to $300 per year
• Storage fee: $100 to $300 per year (segregated storage costs more than commingled)
• Dealer markup: 3% to 8% over spot on the initial purchase, and again on any future purchases

On a $25,000 account, those ongoing fees ($175 to $600 per year) represent 0.7% to 2.4% of your account value. That is before your gold appreciates a single dollar. Compare that to a Vanguard Total Stock Market fund at 0.03% per year. The gap is massive.

For my $50,000 account, I pay roughly $225 per year in combined custodian and storage fees. That is about 0.45%, which I consider acceptable for what I am getting: physical gold sitting in segregated storage with tax-deferred growth. But if my account were $15,000, those same $225 in fees would represent 1.5% annually, and I would seriously question whether the math makes sense.

What it costs: Over 20 years, you will pay $4,000 to $12,000 in custodian and storage fees alone. Add the initial dealer markup and you could be looking at $6,000 to $16,000 in total ownership costs on a $50,000 account.

How to avoid it: Before opening an account, get every fee in writing. Ask for a complete fee schedule. Calculate the total annual cost as a percentage of your planned account balance. If it exceeds 1%, your account is probably too small for a gold IRA to make sense. I lay out all five fees you need to watch in my hidden gold IRA fees breakdown.

Mistake 5: The "Home Storage IRA" Trap

Every few months I see an ad or a forum post promoting the idea that you can store your IRA gold at home. The pitch goes like this: set up an LLC, make the LLC the trustee of your self-directed IRA, buy gold through the LLC, keep the gold in a safe in your closet. No depository fees. No custodian fees. Total control.

Sounds great. The IRS disagrees.

The IRS has gone after home storage IRA arrangements repeatedly, and they have won every case that has gone to court. In the McNulty case (2017), the Tax Court ruled that storing IRA metals at home constituted a taxable distribution. The entire account value was treated as distributed, triggering income tax on the full amount plus the 10% early withdrawal penalty. The investors were trying to save a couple hundred dollars a year in storage fees. They ended up owing thousands in taxes and penalties.

I pay $150 per year for segregated storage at an IRS-approved depository. That is $12.50 a month. For that price I get insured vault storage, quarterly statements confirming my holdings, and zero risk of the IRS blowing up my entire retirement account. I cannot think of a worse place to cut corners.

What it costs: If the IRS catches it, you owe income tax on the full account value plus the 10% early withdrawal penalty if you are under 59 and a half. On a $75,000 account for someone in the 24% tax bracket, that is roughly $25,500 in taxes and penalties.

How to avoid it: Store your metals at an IRS-approved depository. Full stop. The companies I recommend (Augusta, Goldco, Birch Gold) all work with established depositories like Delaware Depository and Brinks. Let them handle it.

Mistake 6: Choosing the Wrong Dealer

Not all gold IRA dealers are the same, and the differences can cost you real money. I spent a full week talking to multiple dealers before I committed, and the variation in quality, pricing, and approach was striking.

Red flags I encountered during my research (I wrote a full guide on gold IRA company red flags if you want the deep dive):

• Pressure to buy immediately. One company I called (not one I recommend) wanted me to commit on the first phone call. High-pressure tactics on a five-figure retirement decision? No thanks.
• Vague pricing. If a rep will not tell you the exact markup over spot before you commit, walk away. Every legitimate dealer should provide this.
• Pushing collector coins. As I covered in Mistake 2, this is about their margin, not your best interest.
• No BBB rating or poor reviews. I checked BBB, Trustpilot, and Google Reviews for every company I considered. The good dealers had years of consistent five-star reviews. The sketchy ones had patterns of complaints about hidden fees and misleading sales tactics.
• Unrealistic promises. Anyone who tells you gold "always goes up" or guarantees a specific return is lying to you. Gold dropped 28% between 2011 and 2015. It happens.

The three companies I trust (Augusta, Goldco, and Birch Gold) all passed my due diligence. Each has BBB accreditation, years of consistent positive reviews, and transparent business practices. They have clear differences in minimums, pricing, and style, which I cover in my precious metals IRA guide. But none of them set off the alarm bells I felt with lesser-known dealers.

What it costs: A bad dealer can hit you with hidden fees, inflated markups, and products that underperform. The difference between a 4% markup and a 12% markup on $50,000 is $4,000 out of your pocket on day one.

How to avoid it: Request information kits from at least two or three companies. Compare pricing, read reviews across multiple platforms, and never commit on the first call.

Mistake 7: Not Planning Distributions Before You Open the Account

This one bit me. Not financially, but it caused headaches I could have avoided.

When I opened my gold IRA, I was focused on getting in: the rollover, the metal selection, the fees. I did not spend five minutes thinking about how I would eventually take money out. That was a mistake, because the distribution process for a gold IRA is more complex than withdrawing cash from a regular IRA.

You have two options when it is time to take distributions:

• Liquidate for cash. The custodian sells your metals, and you receive a cash distribution. Simple, but you are subject to whatever the spot price is at the time. You also pay the dealer's buyback spread, which is typically 1% to 3% below spot.
• In-kind distribution. You receive the actual physical metals. Gold Eagles, silver bars, whatever you own. The fair market value on the date of distribution counts as taxable income (for traditional IRAs). You then own the physical metals personally.

I eventually decided I wanted to take some distributions in kind. But I learned too late that certain products are easier to distribute in kind than others. Fractional-ounce coins (1/10 oz Gold Eagles, for example) give you more flexibility because you can distribute smaller dollar amounts. If your entire IRA is in one-ounce bars and you need a $5,000 distribution, the math gets awkward.

What it costs: Poor distribution planning does not cost you a penalty, but it can cost you in bad timing, unfavorable liquidation prices, and a scramble to reorganize your holdings at the worst possible moment.

How to avoid it: Before you select your metals, think about how and when you plan to access them. Talk to your custodian about distribution logistics. Consider holding a mix of product sizes so you have flexibility later.

Mistake 8: Skipping Due Diligence on Custodians and Depositories

Most investors focus all their research energy on the dealer and completely overlook the custodian and depository. That is like researching the car dealer and ignoring the car.

Your custodian is the financial institution that actually holds your IRA. They file reports with the IRS, process transactions, and manage your account. If they are disorganized, slow, or poorly funded, your experience will be miserable regardless of how good your dealer is.

Your depository is where your physical metals live. It should be insured, audited regularly, and approved by the IRS. The two names you will hear most are Delaware Depository and Brinks Global Services. Both have excellent reputations.

Questions I wish I had asked before my first rollover:

• Which custodian will hold my account, and what is their track record?
• Which depository will store my metals, and what insurance do they carry?
• Can I choose between segregated and commingled storage?
• How quickly can the custodian process a distribution request?
• What happens to my metals if the custodian goes out of business?

For what it is worth, your metals belong to you regardless of what happens to the custodian or depository. If either goes under, your holdings transfer to a new institution. But the transition can take weeks, and during that time your account may be frozen. Choosing stable, established companies minimizes that risk.

What it costs: A poorly run custodian can mean delayed transactions, botched paperwork, and IRS reporting errors that create tax headaches. A questionable depository puts your physical metals at risk (though insurance should cover losses).

How to avoid it: Ask your dealer specifically who the custodian and depository are. Look them up independently. Check for regulatory actions, customer complaints, and how long they have been in business.

Mistake 9: Forgetting About Required Minimum Distributions

If you have a traditional gold IRA, the IRS requires you to start taking distributions at age 73. These are called Required Minimum Distributions (RMDs), and they apply to gold IRAs the same way they apply to any traditional retirement account.

The problem is that RMDs from a gold IRA are logistically more complicated than RMDs from a stock brokerage account. With stocks, your custodian sells shares and sends you a check. Done. With a gold IRA, you either sell metals at whatever the spot price happens to be, or you take a physical distribution of gold and silver and owe income tax on the fair market value.

Neither option is bad. But both require planning.

If gold prices are low when you are forced to sell for your RMD, you are liquidating at a bad time with no flexibility to wait. If you take an in-kind distribution, you need to arrange secure shipping and storage for the physical metals at your home, and you need to set aside cash to cover the tax bill.

The RMD amount is calculated based on your account balance at the end of the previous year divided by a life expectancy factor from IRS tables. For a 73-year-old, the divisor is approximately 26.5. So if your gold IRA was worth $100,000 at year end, your first RMD would be roughly $3,774. Miss an RMD entirely? The IRS penalty used to be 50% of the amount you should have withdrawn. Under current rules (SECURE 2.0 Act), the penalty dropped to 25%, or 10% if you correct it quickly. Still painful.

Roth gold IRAs, by the way, do not have RMDs during the owner's lifetime under current law. If RMDs concern you and your tax situation allows it, a Roth conversion might be worth discussing with a tax professional. I cover this and six other tax strategies in my gold IRA tax benefits guide.

What it costs: Missing an RMD triggers a 25% penalty on the amount you failed to withdraw (10% if corrected promptly). On a required $4,000 distribution, that is $400 to $1,000 in penalties, plus any income tax you owe.

How to avoid it: Know your RMD start date. Set calendar reminders starting a year before you turn 73. Talk to your custodian about their RMD process and how much lead time they need to liquidate metals or arrange an in-kind distribution. Plan your account holdings so you can meet RMDs without being forced to sell at the worst time.

The Bigger Picture: How I Think About Gold IRA Risk

Every investment has risk. Gold IRAs are no exception. But the risks specific to gold IRAs are almost entirely operational, not market-based. The gold itself will do what gold does: hold value over long periods, spike during crises, occasionally drop 20% to 30% during corrections. You cannot control that.

What you can control is whether you do a direct rollover. Whether you buy bullion or overpriced collector coins. Whether you check fee schedules before signing. Whether you pick a reputable dealer with a long track record. Whether you plan your distributions before you need them.

Every mistake on this list is preventable. That is the good news. The bad news is that the gold IRA industry is not always set up to help you avoid them. Some dealers profit from your ignorance. The best ones (and they do exist) profit from your trust and work to keep it.

I went with Augusta for my own account because they checked every box. Transparent pricing, an educational approach that felt genuine, and a rep who told me not to roll over more than I should. Goldco and Birch Gold are both solid alternatives depending on your account size and preferences. All three have the kind of track record that gives me confidence recommending them.

If you are considering a gold IRA, start with a free information kit. No commitment required. Compare what each company offers, do your own research, and take your time. A gold IRA should protect your retirement, not become a source of regret.

Get Augusta's Free IRA Guide Request Goldco's Free Kit Get Birch Gold's Info Kit